Many people ask ” can pilates help people with Parkinson’s Disease?” To fully understand what is possible it is important to understand what is Parkinson’s Disease (PD). It is the most common neurological condition in Australia with 1 in 340 Australians living with the disease, and Queensland is considered a hotspot for the condition. Nearly 1/4 of all Australians living with Parkinson’s disease live in Queensland. The reasons for the increases in numbers, or the higher prevalence in Queensland, are not clear. Pilates and Parkinson’s Disease is one of the exercise and movement strategies that can help people manage changes in function.
In this article we will explore some simple concepts about :
// What is Parkinson’s Disease?
// What are Lewy bodies?
// What is the Basal Ganglia and Dopamine?
// The 5 categories of Parkinson’s Disease
// Symptoms of Parkinson’s Disease
// Medications and changes to expect.
// Exercise and Parkinson’s Disease
There will be some detailed terms that you may not have come across, and I will attempt to make this simple. If you are wanting to learn more about neuro anatomy we have introduced an Introduction to Neuroanatomy course to help movement teachers better understand the terminology and context of neuroanatomy.
What is Parkinson’s Disease?
Parkinson’s Disease is classified as a movement disorder that is most likely to onset for people in their 50s and 60s. Although about 5 % of Parkinson’s Disease cases occur in people under the age of 40 years. Michael J Fox (actor) is an example of an early onset. There are some known examples of an inherited form of the disease through a mutation in the 4th chromosome, however there is a high suspicion, that the condition is linked to environmental factors such as exposure to manganese, iron, pesticides or repeated head traumas (Mohammed Ali). At this stage there is no confirmed reason why a person will develop PD, what is known is that it is a progressive neurological condition.
What are Lewy Bodies?
Lewy bodies are a description of a build up in the brain of a protein called alpha-synuclein. This particular protein deposit has been identified in a number of diseases including
// Parkinson’s Disease,
// Dementia with Lewy bodies (Alzheimer’s Disease) and
// Multiple System Atrophy (MSA)
Lewy body disease is still not well understood, making it difficult to diagnose during the early stages of the disease. A raft of problems can result in confusing symptoms in :
// the autonomic nervous system (the system that automatically regulates bodily functions such as breath and temperature),
// cognition(thinking), behavioural, or
// motor functions.
It is for this reason that it can be hard to identify if a person has Parkinson’s Disease or some of the other Lewy body conditions. The role of the Lewy bodies in these particular conditions is not well understood but it is thought that when the protein is damaged it starts to lay down these particular Lewy bodies. In the case of PD the Lewy bodies are laid down in the substantia nigra of the Basal Ganglia which is an important site for Dopamine and movement.
What is the role of the Basal Ganglia and Dopamine?
The Basal Ganglia does sound like Thai food, but it is really an important part of the brain. It is essentially an area deep in our brain that serves as our movement centre. The Basal Ganglia can be considered an editor for movement inputs and outputs and helps with the regulation of a neurotransmitter called Dopamine. Neurotransmitters are the chemicals that are produced by our body so that the nerves achieve certain actions eg. movement, relaxation, contraction of muscles, and so forth. There is a lot of chemistry required for the nerves to work. Diseases such as Parkinson’s Disease affects the chemistry of the brain, in particular, Dopamine, so that movement becomes dysfunctional. Dopamine is a neurotransmitter that regulates smooth muscle control and inhibits the release of another neurotransmitter known as GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid). Dopamine encourages movement and GABA inhibits movement.
Accordingly, when there is too much Dopamine in our body we can have too much movement, in conditions like Huntington’s Disease, whilst when there is not enough movement we can start to freeze up which is what happens in conditions such as Parkinson’s Disease. As this is a chemistry process, medications (LevoDopa) are often used to replace the missing Dopamine, but this medication does not stop the underlying condition it just treats the symptoms.
The Basal Ganglia, neurotransmitters, and other sections of our brain are explained in more detail and context in our online Introduction to Anatomy and Teaching Basics course for those people wanting to learn more about the language of neuroanatomy.
Symptoms of Parkinson’s Disease
Four symptoms are considered cardinal in PD:
Bradykinesia is the slowing down and loss of spontaneous movement. You might recall that when we spoke about the neurotransmitters Dopamine and GABA and how these different chemicals affect movement. This loss of movement and freezing increases over time and much of the movement and exercise strategies discussed later in this article are aimed at addressing this particular symptom.
Tremor, in the early stages of Parkinson’s Disease has a distinct pattern and is evident in about 70% of cases. It is called a resting tremor that is generally very specifically identifiable when a person is not using a particular limb and will be more evident on one particular side. In the early stages of the disease a person will be able to control the tremor by engaging in activities such as grasping onto an object and moving. It is important to remember that a resting tremor is different to an essential tremor. Many people have what is known as an essential tremor, and mistakenly think that they have Parkinson’s Disease.
Rigidity, refers to the resistance felt in muscles when they are passively moved. This can be described as “lead pipe” rigidity when the resistance is consistent. “Cogwheel” rigidity is the term used when the resistance to passive movements has a regular jerking characteristic. Muscle rigidity, as with all PD symptoms, first presents as unilateral (one sided) however with progression becomes bilateral. Muscle rigidity accounts for the neck and shoulder pain sometimes experienced early in the disease process. Hypomimia (or facial masking) is a medical sign where there is a reduced degree of facial expression and is often seen in people with Parkinson’s Disease and also MS.
Postural instability Postural changes are evident as forward flexed or stooped posture. The ability to maintain posture and balance may be affected in PD. This symptom may appear later and is often the cause of falls because the ability to correct one’s balance is compromised. This may lead to unsteadiness when walking, turning or standing.
Other symptoms include:
Dystonia, or abnormal posturing, can accompany PD and can be very painful. Some typical patterns of dystonia include curling of the toes or inward turning of the foot. Dystonia may appear when there is a decrease in brain Dopamine levels, which could occur first thing in the morning before taking medication or when a dose of medication is wearing off. If this is the pattern that is noted, various strategies can be implemented to decrease the OFF time. Dystonia can also be a side effect of treatment with levodopa. This on-off effect is discussed later in this article.
Voice loss or a very soft voice can be another symptom and can be addressed with Speech Therapists.
Apathy, Adhonia ( the loss of enjoyment), anxiety, cognitive decline and depression are all other symptoms of Parkinson’s Disease.
Micrographia is an acquired disorder that features abnormally small, cramped handwriting or the progression to progressively smaller handwriting. It is commonly associated with neurodegenerative disorders of the Basal Ganglia, such as in Parkinson’s disease.
The symptoms are very distinct and are generally managed through medication, physical therapies and exercise. The general focus of most treatment is at a symptom level aimed at maintaining physical, emotional, and cognitive function for as long as possible.
Remember when working with a person who has Parkinson’s Disease remember they have family and friends who are also needing care and support as well. Sometimes your class program is about allowing the carer respite or an opportunity to do something for their body and health at the same time.
The stages of Parkinson’s Disease
There are considered to be 5 stages of Parkinson’s Disease ( Hoehn & Yahr, 1967)
Stage 1 – Unilateral symptoms, no or minimal functional implications, usually a resting tremor
Stage 2 – Midline or bilateral symptom, no balance difficulty, mild problems with trunk mobility and postural reflexes
Stage 3 – Postural instability, mild to moderate functional disability
Stage 4 – Postural instability increasing, though still able to walk, functional disability increasing with impact on Activities of Daily Living, decreased manipulation and dexterity.
Stage 5 – Confined to a wheelchair
No one can say when exactly a person with Parkinson’s Disease will enter into a particular stage and how long the person will stay in a particular stage. What is generally recommended is that those experiencing the disease maintain and regularly review their medication and stay physically strong throughout the disease to remain independent for as long as possible.
Medications and treatments
Initial therapy is usually levodopa (administered with carbidopa), is the most effective treatment available for the management of motor symptoms of PD, including rigidity. However, it can cause a side effect known as dyskinesia, which are abnormal involuntary movements. Dopamine agonists are less effective on the motor symptoms of PD but have a lower rate of causing dyskinesia, although they have other side effects. MAO-B inhibitors are less effective than levodopa or dopamine agonists, however they have fewer side effects.
Choice of medications is dependent on the individual who will need an understanding of the risks and benefits of each class of medication. A person’s neurologist will oversee the medications and their will be regular reviews. However, in a movement class it is important to understand what medications a person is taking as it can have certain side affects including dyskenesia. This video is a good explanation of the process of the dyskinesia and what is called an “on-off ” affect of the medication. Understanding this process is important for timing of activities and exercise classes for people living with Parkinson’s Disease.
Deep Brain Stimulation
LevoDopa eventually loses its effectiveness for people with Parkinson’s Disease, and this is when some people have deep brain stimulation. Not everyone is suitable for deep brain stimulation and it is not given to those people with :
// cognitive or dementia-related complications.
For those of you interested in the process, the video below is interesting in how it explains the role of Deep Brain stimulation and what is done to reduce the tremor. The video is about 30 minutes long, so you may want to save this article and video until later.
Exercise and Parkinson’s Disease
There is a lot of research happening about exercise and Parkinson’s Disease, such as the LSVT program ( see below video ), Parkinson’s Warriors and many other programs. A recent meta-analysis of pilates (Suárez-Iglesias , Miller, Seijo-Martínez, & Ayán, 2019) showed that pilates plays an effective role in movement programs for people with Parkinson’s Disease. The common themes in the exercise focus was:
// Larger movements
// faster movements
// specific cueing and movement principles
In the video below you can see ideas from one such program on big movement patterns and activities. When I look at some of these exercises you can see how they incorporate common exercises seen in pilates and gyrotonic method. It is just that these exercises are done with more force than normal.
Some ideas that can incorporate large stepping movements, easily using the pilates apparatus and traditional exercises. Just the focus and cueing strategies are different.
Cueing is important whenever you teach and work with people. When working with clients with PD the best practice guidelines (Occupational Therapy for people with Parkinson’s, 2015) suggest three key principles:
a. Conscious attention is required for the performance of well-learnt motor skills and movement sequences
b Consider the value of limiting multitasking and of practicing instead only certain selected multitask activities
c Encourage the use of cognitive and sensory cues and triggers to guide the flow of motor performance and ideas.
- Some recommended intrinsic cues include:
- Reminding people of a positive attitude and encourage a positive emotional set
- mental rehearsal (Morris, 2000)
- Internal dialogues (Farley & Koshland, 2005; Maitra, 2007)Visualisation ( Tamir et al 2007)
- Extrinsic cueing techniques include important factors of:
- Visual environment – means that when you set up your exercise space avoid patterned floors and carpets as it can contribute to confusion and freezing.
- Use visual cues like floor markers that are colour contrasting. These floor markers can be used in doorways or pathways as cues to help with movement and maintain flow of gait.
- Cue cards with a list of actions and reminders of the steps to perform a specific task
- Verbal cues (Behrman et el 1998) need to be loud and specific especially aimed at initiating movement and maintaining flow
- Metronomes (Lim et el 2005a, 2005b, Rochester et el. 2005) have been shown useful to help people overcome the start-stop freezing. The beat rates that appear to be most effective are 110-120 beats per minute for women and at 105-115 beats per minute for men.
- Music and rhythm. Rhythm has been shown to be a key part of working with clients who have PD.
Gait and drop foot ideas
In our drop foot coueaw we discuss more ideas about what to be done to help people with gait problems. You can also learn more about this in one of our online Anatomy Dimensions course.
Balance is an issue for many conditions not just for people with neurological conditions. We explain more about balance and ideas for balance in this article . If you are interested in learning more about balance issues try our online course “Chucking a wobbly”
Here is a small class using Makarlu to help with drop foot, which is explored more deeply in our Anatomy Dimensions Feet course and Pelvis courses
Here is a Balance class that is explored more deeply in our Chucking a Wobbly course.
Hypomimia (masked face), and neck and shoulder problems
Some of the earliest experienced symptoms of PD, are neck and shoulder problems. In this video we have incorporated a simple series of exercises that can be done at home. If you are interested in learning more about these specific issues not just for Parkinson’s disease try our online Anatomy Dimensions courses. Below is a video from our neck and jaw course that can help with tension and problems in the face and jaw.
For those interested in neurological conditions and Parkinson’s Disease we will be releasing the Introduction to Anatomy and Teaching Basics at the end of April 2021.
In 2021 Carla Mullins will be presenting the Parkinson’s Disease course ( part of which is available online ) and some of her other neurological conditions based courses online and throughout Australia. For those interested in attending those courses contact us at email@example.com
[maxbutton id=”31″ ]
A Samii, JG Nutt, BR Ransom Parkinson’s disease Lancet 363, 1783-1793, 2004
Behrman AL, Teitelbaum P, Cauraugh JH (1998) Verbal instructional sets to normalise the temporal and spatial gait variables in Parkinson’s disease. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 65(4), 580–582.
Farley BG, Koshland GF (2005) Training BIG to move faster: the application of the speed-amplitude relation as a rehabilitation strategy for people with Parkinson’s disease. Experimental Brain Research,167(3), 462–467.
Goedert, M., Jakes, R., & Spillantini, M.G. (2017). The Synucleinopathies: Twenty Years On. Journal of Parkinson’s disease.
Hoehn M, Yahr M (1967) Parkinsonism: onset, progression and mortality. Neurology, 17(5), 427–442.
Lim LIIK, Van Wegen EEH, De Goede CJT, Jones D, Rochester L, Hetherington V, Nieuwboer AM, Willems A, Kwakkel G (2005a) Measuring gait and gait-related activities in Parkinson’s patients’ own home environment: a reliability, responsiveness and feasibility study. Parkinsonism and Related Disorders, 11(1), 19–24.
Maitra KK (2007) Enhancement of reaching performance via self-speech in people with Parkinson’s disease. Clinical Rehabilitation, 21(5), 418–424.
Morris ME (2000) Movement disorders in people with Parkinson’s disease: a model for physical therapy. Physical Therapy, 80(6), 578–597.
Suárez-Iglesias, D., Miller, K. J., Seijo-Martínez, M., & Ayán, C. (2019). Benefits of Pilates in Parkinson’s Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Medicina, 55(8), 476. MDPI AG. Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/medicina55080476
Tamir R, Dickstein R, Huberman M (2007) Integration of motor imagery and physical practice in group treatment applied to subjects with Parkinson’s disease. Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair, 21(1), 68–75.
[maxbutton id=”31″ ]